Forums Forums 8-Page Challenge #1 for NYCC 2020 (COMPLETED) #8PgChallenge – STEP 5 – Scripting

  • buddyscalera

    May 9, 2020 at 3:50 am


    We are making progress! If you are following along with the schedule, you know that this is a big step.

    Please review this post on writing the first draft of your script. Then use the ATTACH button at the bottom of this thread and attach your script.

    How to Write the Script for Your 8-Page Comic Story | #8PgChallenge – Step 5

    As with previous steps, please provide feedback to each other here on the message boards. You may also want to participate in small writing groups to give direct feedback. Do whatever works for you.

  • george-dawkins-ii

    May 9, 2020 at 5:13 am

    Here is my script

  • krisburgos

    May 9, 2020 at 8:54 am

    @gdawkins2 Hey! Just finished reading your script, it’s a tight read, though I feel it’s a little too tight. I see that majority of your pages have 1 or 2 panels, and I think one of your pages doesn’t even have description to it, it’s just the dialogue. Unless you’ve already discussed with your artist that they’re gonna have to do most of the legwork, like the old school marvel way based on your plotting, there’s not enough description for the artist to work with. And I can tell you, if you are planning on single or 2 panel pages, it’ll make your story feel less like a comic book and more like a storybook. The cool thing about comics is that they have multiple panels conveying multiple actions, which I know you want in your story. Storybooks are more static single pictures working off some pages of text. And too many splash pages (single panel pages) feel like a storybook. Don’t be afraid to flesh out the script a little to give the artist some direction, because without it, your artist could surprise you and give you something completely opposite of what you actually want. Good luck!

  • george-dawkins-ii

    May 9, 2020 at 9:01 am

    @krisburgos Thanks still getting used to this formatting

  • jholder12

    May 9, 2020 at 6:40 pm

    Here is the script I’m doing with @evanscale Thank you all!

  • psysci

    May 9, 2020 at 7:32 pm

    Here is my script for Parasomniac

    I’ve been working a bit outside of the process. Revising it based on feedback and diving into the pages artwork a bit early.

  • evolver

    May 9, 2020 at 10:55 pm

    @jholder I just finished your script. Really well done, there might be a few line edits I would do for language, but otherwise I think you nailed the self-contained story in 8 pages concept. It was a really well done vignette in the lives of these characters and gave me a sense of a large narrative in which they were contained.

  • evolver

    May 9, 2020 at 10:56 pm

    the comment above was for you … misspeled your username.

  • evolver

    May 9, 2020 at 11:03 pm

    My script is attached. I’m going to be drawing it, so for pages/panels where I had a clear sense of how they shoudl fit together I added more detail so I would remember when thumbnailing.

  • david-shear

    May 10, 2020 at 1:02 am

    Script’s done!

  • toddmatthy

    May 10, 2020 at 8:31 am

    Here is the script for “Respect.”

  • jarrod-elvin

    May 10, 2020 at 10:46 am

    Here is my script; second draft after a bit of feedback, happy for more!
    I didn’t go into too much detail in the panel descriptions, I feel I’d explore that better visually while I’m doing the thumbnails.
    Hope you enjoy! 😀

  • andresbriano

    May 11, 2020 at 1:02 am

    Hey colleagues,
    Here’s my first draft of “Twilight of the Gods Prophecy” It’s in decent shape. But I need to rework pages 6 and 7 because they are too compressed. The art will be provided by @gaston and the colors will be done by @majaopacic.
    Constructive criticism welcome!


  • thesurrealari

    May 11, 2020 at 4:28 am

    Here is the current draft of my script for Mr. Stupendous. Thank you to those who provided feedback on the plot. I’ve incorporated some of it here,

    A couple of focus questions for your consideration:

    1. I considered two insets on P1, but ultimately decided against them. The first was of Mr. Stupendous telling his wife he would have to work late; the second was of him on the receiving end of the punch that gave him the black eye. If I include these, they would, most likely be in thought bubbles, as he is remembering the night while looking in the window (Think of the old Will Eisner-style opening splash pages from The Spirit). Do you think I should add them back in or leave the page as is (with just the one panel)?
    2. On page 3, should I add a panel where the sky darkens forebodingly before the actual rain starts. It would allow me to have the sky blue when he starts flying, adding to the comic effect, but I’m not sure that’s entirely necessary.
    3. On page four, do you think there needs to be one more panel showing him changing (possibly while walking down the stairwell)
    4. On the turn from 7-8: Do you think I should move the first panel from page 8 back to page 7? Part of me thinks it’s really part of that action, but I don’t want to crowd the page.

    A couple of other notes:

    1. There aren’t any character descriptions in the comic, because they appear in the character design document I sent my artist a couple of weeks ago.
    2. The script is not fully proofed yet. I find it silly to proofread before the text is finalized, as, if changes are made, you have to do the work twice.
    • mrkylerose

      May 16, 2020 at 9:11 am

      Hey @thesurrealari,

      I read your script and it’s really solid. You’ve paced it well, and the repetition of “stupendous” helps create a nice rhythm. You manage to establish a lot in 8 pages. The tension of his wife not knowing he’s a hero really helps increase the stakes. There is also a nice interplay between the sense of loneliness this is causing for Stupendous and the moments of levity that help balance out the tone. I know you mentioned this is part of a larger series, so is this the first one? It feels very like you’ve set the scene for a much much larger story here. If I have an overall bit of feedback its that you introduce so many facets of Stupendous’ life, I leave the story with more questions than answers. However, once again, given this is part of a series, I’d say that approach helps to make the reader want to come back for more. Overall, great work, and you have me hooked! More specific notes below:

      On page one, I like how you integrated the title into the flow of the voice-over. Nice touch. I think you made the right call leaving out the inserts. I feel like you get the same context across without them.

      Page two: I love the idea of the two connecting panels (5/6). Have you thought about making this one panel and having the ‘separation’ between the beats be something ‘practical’ like the door frame creating a faux gutter?

      Page three: I don’t think you need the extra panel of the sky turning dark. I do think you can draw the readers’ attention to this by having him look up at the darker sky in panel 3 as if he’s assessing the weather.

      Page four: No need to show him changing back, by this point the reader can fill in that blank. Also, I love how Stupendous turns an accusation of abuse into innuendo thereby making the receptionist uncomfortable to ask further questions. NOTE: this only works because we KNOW its not abuse. Otherwise, I would say it’s in poor taste.

      Page 5 is really well done, I might even say its stupendous! (sorry couldn’t resist.)

      The fourth wall breaking of the narrator is a great gag on page 6.

      I’d keep the panels how you have them on pages 7-8.

      Hope that helps!

  • krisburgos

    May 11, 2020 at 5:52 am

    Here’s No Shelter. Still going to tweak some dialogue. I want to possibly add internal monologues for Kaia to give an idea what she’s thinking. Right now, she’s a little bare bones.

    • krisburgos

      May 11, 2020 at 9:32 am

      Whoops, this was the one I meant to submit, the supplemental story info changed. That’s all

  • mrkylerose

    May 11, 2020 at 10:17 am

    Hey Everyone,

    Here is the first draft of my full script. One note on how I work when I’m writing and drawing: I tend to change things up through the thumbnail process as an act of discovery. So it’s never too late for feedback. Speaking of, I have a few specific questions listed below, but I am looking for any and all feedback. I have attached a pdf of the script but also have provided a google drive link with commenting permissions. If you could I would prefer that you make comments directly in the google doc:

    Here are my questions:
    — Is the last bit of dialogue on page one (panel 5 & 6) too on the nose?
    — Did I go a little too hard on the speculative future slang? (preeb, dusties, fidget, etc)
    — Should I add one more action beat to page 4 and merge the last panel on that page with the first panel on page 5?
    — Page 5, panel 4: is the dialogue too on the nose?
    — Page 6, should panel 5 be its own close-up or just be integrated into the background of panel 4. Also, does this bit feel too deus ex machina?
    — Should I move the first panel on page 8 to be the last thing on page 7 and leave page 8 solely for an ‘epilogue’ or should I leave the reveal until the last page?
    — Does Abigail’s language sound like a crass teen girl or does it sound more like a cynical 30 plus-year-old man? lol.

    Thanks, everyone. I look forward to reading your scripts and can’t wait to hear what you have to say about mine!


    • thesurrealari

      May 15, 2020 at 6:36 am


      I just read your script, and I think it’s pretty strong. I like the future slang. It’s a nice world-building technique, and I don’t think it’s too much. I also like the detail of the gun mark to differentiate the time machine in the two streams. I do think you can adjust Abigail’s dialogue a bit to make her feel younger. Maybe use some more slang beyond the cursing, or giving her a pet phrase of dialogue quirk to make her speech pattern feel more unique. Also, nd this is a matter of personal preference, but have you considered moving the title card to the first page? When I have my stories in anthologies, I like to have the credits right up front so that the reader knows it’s our (myself and my artists’) story, and it’s easy for them to find our names if they like it or if they are just flipping through the book. I do really like the last bit of dialogue with the dramatic irony of her her knowing and the parents not knowing. The irony works well in the end. I also like the reveal as is. I would keep the turn from 7-8 as you currently have it. As long as you only see her reaction in that last panel on 7, the reveal isn’t spoiled. If anything, it’s enhanced by the suspense of wondering what she saw.

  • george-dawkins-ii

    May 12, 2020 at 12:37 am

    Here’s a more fleshed out draft of my script

    • mrkylerose

      May 16, 2020 at 9:32 am

      Hey @gdawkins2,
      I just read Lavatasha, You have some really nice action beats and Lavatasha feels like an authentic post-millennial youth (god I feel old typing that). The “tag me” bit of dialogue really helps sell that. This script does feel a little sparse even though I read the ‘fleshed out’ version. I’d suggest pushing it even further.

      Black Ice’s motivation is really interesting. I would try to find a way to ‘show not tell’ this reveal. Maybe before he enters the bank we see him looking at toys or children’s clothes through a shop window. etc. Something that helps integrate it more organically.

      I would flesh out some of your scene descriptions. Especially the establishing shot on page 1, Panel 1. Establishing shots are always great opportunities to include some bits of visual foreshadowing and/or worldbuilding.

      I like the interplay between Lavatasha and Ice. They seem vaguely friendly even though they are rivals.

      You should have them doing something while they talk on page 4. This would add a bit of context to the scene. Like is Black Ice just continuing his heist while they are talking or are they starting to fight while they banter? etc.

      I have a question for you to consider: What’s your main goal here? Is it your intent to establish Lavatasha as a character. Do you want us to empathize with Black Ice’s situation? Is this an unusual mentor-mentee situation even though they are on opposite sides of the law? I’d try to tack that down and lean into it during your revisions.

      Overall this is off to a great start. Keep going! I look forward to seeing how it develops.

  • toddmatthy

    May 13, 2020 at 9:44 am

    Here’s the script to my second story, “Hole in the Sky.” Let me know what you think. And if you need a critique, message me.


    • This reply was modified 10 months ago by  toddmatthy.
  • george-dawkins-ii

    May 14, 2020 at 8:34 am

    @toddmatthy I read the script for your “Respect” story. As a pro wrestling fan I thought it was good. I suggest that you provide your artist with clips for reference of the wrestling moves being used (DDT, “pelvaplex”, etc.) just in case they don’t know pro wrestling like we do. Also, after reading your script, Crusher Christian reminded me a lot of Dr. D David Schultz. The Dark Side of the Ring episode on him came out a few weeks ago, and if you haven’t already I recommend that you watch it and maybe even your artist too for a better idea of CC’s character.

  • george-dawkins-ii

    May 16, 2020 at 6:25 pm


    Thanks for the feedback!

    Addressing your points, I’m thinking that maybe after Black Ice breaks into the bank there could be a baby crying in a stroller that he notices which could also qualify as a bit of foreshadowing.

    I’ll definitely work on fleshing out the description of the bank on page 1. On page 4, maybe Black Ice could be freezing the vault/safe door to make it brittle and Lavatasha stops him after she comes in by causing lava to erupt from the ground in front of him.

    My main goal is to hopefully continue this story by introducing Lavatasha and her status as a popular superhero here while leaving readers with a mystery they may want to find out in a later comic.

  • andresbriano

    May 18, 2020 at 12:51 am

    Ladies and gentlemen,
    Here’s a final draft of Twilight of the Gods that I am proud of. I think it flows nicely and that everything is properly tied up together.
    @Gaston and I have been conferring about it, and any tweaks from now on, might just happen verbally between us.

    Constructive criticism welcome.


  • thesurrealari

    May 18, 2020 at 2:13 am

    My script has been submitted to my artist, @artsmermaid. Thank you to all those who provided feedback, especially @mywritinghero and @mrkylerose whose notes were particularly insightful.

  • toddmatthy

    May 18, 2020 at 5:12 am

    Hi Jarrod, I like this story. Its fun and imaginative. The only thing I’d do is reduce the amount of dialogue you have because I don’t see how it’ll all fit into a panel. I’d made a list of panels where I think this will be useful. Hope this helps.

    1.2: I’d make this less wordy.
    2.3: I’d show the girls getting serious instead.
    3.1: I’d cut the entirety of IO’s first round of dialogue. The next two lines sum up what you need to get across.

    Your story flows really well, however some panels are missing descriptions and only have dialogue which made it difficult to figure out the story’s rhythm. I made some suggestions for adjustments based on what I’ve read to help things flow better. Hope it helps.

    3.1-I’d cut this and have Lavatasha immediately have her entrance.
    4.1: Move this dialogue to the previous page.
    4.2: Move Lavatasha’s dialogue up to 4.1
    4.3-4.4: Combine these.

  • toddmatthy

    May 18, 2020 at 5:29 am

    I like this a lot. I also like how you included a grid for your artist. Below were some nuts and bolts I thought I’d share.

    1.2: I’d cut the first caption.
    4.2: I’d cut the parchment caption.

  • jarrod-elvin

    May 18, 2020 at 8:31 am

    @toddmatthy Thank you so much! I will edit this accordingly.
    I did get another piece of feedback suggesting I should have the girls (main characters) speak some dialogue sooner, because as it is they don’t have any dialogue themselves until page 3.

  • mrkylerose

    May 18, 2020 at 9:15 am

    Hey Everyone!

    Here is my revised script. As per my normal process, it might change slightly when I get into drawing it. Special thanks to @mywritinghero and @thesurrealari for their feedback. Like last time, I’d love to hear any and all feedback. Below is a google doc link with commenting privileges and I have attached a pdf.

    Thanks, everyone!

  • jarrod-elvin

    May 18, 2020 at 5:29 pm

    Hi everyone, here is an updated draft of my script, based off the feedback I was given. I guess you could call it the final draft, although I might change it up a bit while doing the thumbnails if I can make the panels more efficient. That’s normally how I work by writing and doing the artwork myself. Thank you for the feedback, please feel free to give me some more if you think it’s needed. Hope you enjoy!

  • andresbriano

    May 18, 2020 at 7:44 pm

    Hey @Toddmatthy,
    Thanks for volunteering a critique. Your time is appreciated.
    I have just read Respect, BTW. I think it’s well paced and that it has the right amount of story for 8 pages. There’s some specific wrestling terminology that I did not get, but aside from that, I wouldn’t change anything.


  • krisburgos

    May 18, 2020 at 9:25 pm

    Here’s the script for the second story I’m doing with @mikedoestheart. It is based on characters of mine from a book called Teddies, which I’ve rebranded as Horrorbook: A Teddy Adventure. If anyone’s got the time, go ahead and check it out.

  • john-ashton-golden

    May 25, 2020 at 3:05 am


    Hey there fellow comics creators!

    When I drafted my plot, I brought my girlfriend (a writer herself, and relatively new fan of comics) in to help me sort out some of the early plot points. In the end, I decided she should be credited as co-plotter. I’ve been swamped with multiple freelance deadlines at the moment, so asked her if she had an interest in following the guidelines for this Comic Book School project and drafting a script based on our plot. She rose to the occasion and did an excellent job! I am definitely going to make another pass and get it to where I want it, but she created some new details for me to chew on, and was a huge help. From there, we’ll discuss and bring it to a final version to begin thumbnailing from. Third time’s a charm!

    Second draft coming soon!

  • aesthetic-derelict

    June 22, 2020 at 5:53 am

    My script.

  • john-ashton-golden

    September 13, 2020 at 6:09 pm

    Attached are versions 1 and 2 of my script. I have a co-writer, Rhonda Raisor. V2 is just about where I want it in terms of page layouts but may make some dialogue tweaks in the lettering phase.

Log in to reply.

Original Post
0 of 0 posts June 2018